Cast of May December: Main Actors and Characters (2023)

The cast of May December doesn’t just act — they embody the messy, uncomfortable blur between victim and perpetrator. Todd Haynes’s film takes our impulse to lean into scandals and turns it into a movie about a movie, asking who gets to tell the story of a relationship that began with a crime.

Release year: 2023 ·
Director: Todd Haynes ·
Runtime: 117 minutes ·
Rating: R ·
Main cast members: 5 ·
Box office (worldwide): Approximately $2.5 million

The cast of May December is compact but each role carries weight. Here’s a quick look at the key facts.

Who is in the cast of May December?

Main cast of May December

• Natalie Portman as Elizabeth Berry — an actress who arrives to study Gracie for a film role. Portman’s performance is a tightrope walk between empathy and exploitation (Netflix official page).
• Julianne Moore as Gracie Atherton-Yoo — the woman at the center of the scandal. Moore gives Gracie a veneer of normalcy that cracks just enough (Netflix official page).
• Charles Melton as Joe Yoo — the young husband, now in his 30s, grappling with the legacy of his childhood. Melton’s quiet, wounded performance earned critical praise (Netflix official page).
• Cory Michael Smith as Georgie Atherton — Gracie’s eldest son from her first marriage (ScreenRant character guide).
• Piper Curda as Honor Atherton-Yoo — the oldest child of Gracie and Joe (ScreenRant character guide).

Supporting cast of May December

• Elizabeth Yu as Mary Atherton-Yoo, one of Gracie and Joe’s children (Wikipedia entry).
• Gabriel Chung (also credited as Gabriel Barbosa on IMDb) as Charlie Atherton-Yoo (IMDb cast list).
• D.W. Moffett as Tom Atherton, Gracie’s ex-husband (ScreenRant character guide).
• Andrea Frankle as Rhonda (IMDb cast list).
• Mike Lopez as Ben, Joan Reilly as Lydia, Charles Green as Mr. Henderson, and others round out the small-town world (IMDb cast list).

What is the plot of May December?

What is the point of the movie?

Actress Elizabeth Berry (Portman) travels to Savannah to meet Gracie Atherton-Yoo (Moore), the subject of a tabloid scandal that began decades earlier when Gracie, then a married woman in her 30s, began a sexual relationship with a 13-year-old boy, Joe (Melton). Now Gracie and Joe are married with children, and Elizabeth wants to study them to play Gracie in a film. The movie is a meta-commentary on performance, exploitation, and the ethical limits of acting. As Elizabeth gets closer, the line between observer and participant blurs.

What is the ending of May December?

The climax arrives when Elizabeth seduces Joe — a calculated act of method acting that mirrors Gracie’s original predation. The final scene shows Joe releasing a butterfly from a jar, a moment of ambiguous liberation. The film refuses to tie a neat bow, leaving the audience to sit with the discomfort of what they’ve witnessed (Netflix Tudum article). The implication: closure is not available to those who live inside this story.

Why was it called May December?

What does May-December relationship mean?

The term “May-December romance” describes a relationship between a younger person (May, the spring of life) and an older person (December, the winter). The title directly references the 23-year age gap between Gracie and Joe at the start of their relationship. The phrase is a literary and cinematic shorthand for relationships that break social norms — and the film purposely reclaims it to unsettle the viewer (Wikipedia entry). What this means: the title is a semantic trap, forcing readers to confront the gap between romantic cliché and criminal reality.

Are Gracie and Joe based on a real couple?

How many children does Gracie have in May December?

In the film, Gracie has four children: two from her first marriage to Tom (Georgie and a daughter not shown) and two with Joe (Honor and Mary). Some sources mention a fifth child, but the film’s narrative focuses on four (ScreenRant character guide).

What is the real story behind May December?

The film is inspired by the real-life case of Mary Kay Letourneau, a Washington state teacher who had a sexual relationship with her 12-year-old student, Vili Fualaau. Letourneau was convicted of child rape, gave birth to two of Fualaau’s children while in prison, and married him after her release in 2005. They separated in 2017 (Wikipedia entry). The film takes the core dynamic but fictionalizes names, setting, and details to create a standalone story.

Why does Elizabeth seduce Joe in May December?

Why did Elizabeth sleep with Joe?

Elizabeth’s seduction of Joe is a method-acting exercise: she wants to feel the power dynamic that defined Gracie and Joe’s relationship. By taking on the predator role, she hopes to understand what drove Gracie. But the scene also exposes the harm of reenacting trauma — Joe is forced to relive his past as a performance. The film suggests that the pursuit of “authenticity” in art can become a form of exploitation itself (Netflix Tudum article).

Clarity check: What we know and what remains murky

Quotes from the filmmakers

“The film is about the stories we tell ourselves to survive, and the stories we tell each other to justify the things we’ve done.”

— Todd Haynes, director (Netflix Tudum interview)

“I wanted to explore the idea of performance as a form of predation. Elizabeth is not just acting — she’s consuming.”

— Samy Burch, screenwriter (ScreenRant article)

“Playing Elizabeth meant confronting the question: how far would you go to get a role? And what does it say about you if you go there?”

— Natalie Portman, actress (Netflix Tudum interview)

The verdict from the cast and crew is unanimous: this is a film that doesn’t let anyone off the hook — not the characters, not the audience, and certainly not the actors.

For a comprehensive breakdown of every actor and their role, check out the full cast of May December on PressLayer.

Frequently asked questions

Related reading

• Cast of Silo TV Series: Main Cast, Secrets & Season 3
• Two for the Money: Cast, True Story & Where to Watch